Electric Car Problems: The Dark Side of Green Driving

Are electric vehicles (EVs) really the best choice for a greener future, or do they have a hidden downside? As we focus more on fighting climate change, many see EVs as a key solution. But, a closer look shows there are many issues that question their clear advantage over traditional cars. This piece will dive into the problems and downsides of electric cars. It aims to give a full picture of the challenges behind their eco-friendly look.

• Electric vehicles (EVs) account for only about 1% of the total global vehicle fleet¹.
• Replacing all UK vehicles with EVs would require twice the yearly global cobalt production, three-quarters of the world’s lithium carbonate, and over half of the 2018 global copper production¹.
• Manufacturing an electric car results in significantly higher carbon dioxide emissions compared to a gasoline-powered car¹.
• EVs can emit more carbon dioxide per mile than gasoline cars when charged from coal-fired power plants¹.
• EV subsidies tend to benefit higher-income households, making them a regressive policy¹.

Their Batteries Need Rare Metals

Electric cars are seen as a green solution, but they have a hidden issue. Their batteries need rare and valuable metals that are scarce². This is causing a big problem as more people want electric vehicles.

Lithium and Cobalt Mining

Lithium is key for electric car batteries and comes mainly from Chile, Argentina, and China³. Cobalt, on the other hand, is mostly from the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC)². Sadly, kids as young as seven work in these mines without rules.

This makes us worry about the ethics and politics of getting these metals.

Scarcity of Raw Materials

There’s a big worry about getting enough materials for electric car batteries³. A car like the Chevrolet Bolt needs a lot of metals, including cobalt, nickel, and graphite³. As more cars switch to electric, we’ll need even more of these metals⁴.

The demand for lithium is set to jump by over 40 times by 2040, mainly for electric cars⁴. The European Union is working on a plan to secure these metals for batteries³. But, making sure we get enough metals without harming the planet or people is a big challenge²³⁴.

“To convert the UK’s 31 million cars to electric vehicles, approximately 12% of the world’s copper output would be required, a demand considered unrealistic.”

Making Electric Cars Creates More Emissions

Many think electric cars are better for the planet because they don’t use gasoline. But, making electric cars actually creates more greenhouse gas emissions⁵. This is because of the mining, refining, and making of the car’s parts and battery.

Studies show electric car production can release 16-19 tonnes of CO2. This is more than the 7-10 tonnes made during a gasoline or diesel car’s production⁵. The big reason is the energy needed to make batteries, which is a big part of the emissions.

But, electric cars can be better for the planet if made with renewable energy⁵. In 2022, renewable and carbon-free energy made up 55% of electricity in Minnesota⁵. So, electric cars made in this area have lower emissions than in places using more fossil fuels.

Also, electric vehicles can pay off their initial emissions in 6 to 16 months of use⁵. This makes them a better choice over time⁶. We need to look at the whole life of an electric car to see its true environmental impact.

Electric cars are seen as a clean and green choice, but making them has a big environmental impact⁵. We must look at the whole life of electric vehicles to understand their true environmental effects. This helps us make better choices to cut down on carbon emissions.

“Around half of the emissions from battery production come from the electricity used in manufacturing and assembling the batteries.”⁶

They Are Only as Green as Their Power Sources

The environmental impact of electric cars depends on how they are charged. If charged with electricity from fossil fuels, they can be worse than cars with gasoline engines⁷. But, if charged with renewable energy like solar or wind, they are much better for the planet⁷.

Carbon Footprint of Electricity Generation

The way electricity is made is key to how green electric vehicles are. In the U.S., most energy came from fossil fuels in 2017⁷. In India, 61% of power comes from thermal sources, with coal making up 60% of emissions⁸. This means electric cars charged with such power aren’t as eco-friendly.

But, things are changing for the better. The European Union aims to cut emissions in half by 2030 and even more by 2050⁷. The U.S. has set goals to cut emissions in half by 2030 and make half of new car sales electric by then⁹.

To lessen the environmental impact of electric cars, we need to use more renewable energy like solar and wind⁷. This will lower the carbon footprint of charging electric cars and help create a greener future⁷.

“Forecasts indicate that electric cars offset their environmental impact within 6 to 16 months of average driving in the US or 2 years in the EU when powered by clean energy.”⁷

As we move towards a sustainable future, electric cars’ environmental impact will depend on their charging sources. Using renewable energy can unlock their full potential to cut carbon emissions⁷⁸⁹.

Electric Cars Can Be Expensive to Buy

Electric vehicles (EVs) are pricier than traditional cars upfront¹⁰. Despite this, EV sales have grown, now making up one in seven cars sold worldwide¹⁰. This shows that many people are finding ways to overcome the initial cost hurdle.

Higher Upfront Costs but Lower Operating Expenses

The high cost of EVs comes mainly from the battery technology¹¹. Yet, owning an EV can be cheaper over time because of lower fuel and maintenance costs¹⁰. In Europe, an EV pays off its carbon debt after about 11,000 miles¹⁰. By 2030, owning an EV could cut emissions by 74-77% as electricity gets cleaner¹⁰.

Charging an electric car costs less than filling up a gas car¹⁰. EVs also need less maintenance because they have fewer parts¹⁰. Even though they cost more at first, their lower running costs make them a smart choice in the long run.

The high initial cost of EVs might stop some from buying them. But, the savings on fuel and maintenance make them more affordable over time¹⁰. As EV technology gets better and battery prices drop, the cost difference with traditional cars will shrink. This will make eco-friendly driving more accessible¹¹.

You Can’t Drive as Far in an Electric Car

Electric cars have made big strides, but they still can’t go as far as cars with gasoline¹². Most electric cars can only go 150 miles or less on one charge¹². This makes them great for city driving or short trips, not long road trips¹². Using heaters, air conditioning, or driving in cold weather also cuts down on how far an electric car can go¹².

Recharging an electric car takes a long time, often 30 minutes or more¹². This is much longer than filling up a gas tank, which is a big difference for drivers¹².

The limited electric vehicle range is a big reason why some people hesitate to switch to electric cars¹². Worries about electric car driving range and electric vehicle range anxiety stop many from choosing these eco-friendly cars¹².

Car makers are working hard to improve battery technology and increase the electric car driving range¹². But for now, electric cars can’t match the long distances of cars with gasoline¹². This is something to think about for anyone thinking of switching to an electric vehicle¹².

“The limited electric vehicle range is a significant drawback for many consumers considering a switch to an electric car. Concerns about electric car driving range and electric vehicle range anxiety remain a major barrier to wider adoption of these environmentally-friendly vehicles.”

There Aren’t Enough Charging Points

The growth of electric vehicles has been faster than the creation of charging stations¹³. Even though more charging stations are being added, they don’t match the number of gas stations yet¹⁴. There are about 140,000 ports at around 53,000 stations in the U.S. for electric vehicles¹⁴. Experts think we’ll need about 1.2 million public chargers if half of new U.S. car sales are electric by 2030¹⁴.

Charging Infrastructure Challenges

This is a big problem for electric car owners, especially those without home charging or who travel a lot¹³. Charging an electric car can take up to 30 minutes or more, which is longer than filling up a gas car¹³.

In big cities, there are gaps in EV charging stations, especially in Black and Latino areas¹⁵. Minority areas are falling behind in using EVs, with more stations in White, wealthy areas¹⁵. Without charging stations in areas without private parking, EVs are harder for people to use¹⁵.

Chicago shows most charging stations are in White areas, showing a gap¹⁵. In New York City, charging stations are mostly in rich, White areas, leaving low-income, Black, and neglected areas behind¹⁴.

The Biden administration wants to increase charging stations to over 500,000 by 2030, a big jump from now¹⁵. General Motors plans to add up to 40,000 stations in the U.S. and Canada, focusing on areas that need it most¹⁵.

Cities like Boston, Orlando, Los Angeles, and St. Paul are starting EV car-sharing programs and offering subsidies for EVs to make electric transport more accessible¹⁵. They’re also putting charging stations in Black areas and adding EV fleets for sharing, but more is needed for true EV equality¹⁵.

Pittsburgh is working on a “Mobility Vision Plan” to fix infrastructure gaps and make EVs more available, aiming for mobility justice¹⁵. In New York, Revel is launching electric taxi fleets and big charging stations in Black communities to help EV adoption¹⁵.

The lack of charging stations is a big hurdle in moving to green transport. Efforts are being made to fix this, but more is needed for equal access, especially in under-served areas. With the Biden administration’s goal and car makers’ plans, electric vehicles’ future looks good, but challenges are still there¹³¹⁵¹⁴.

The Dark Side of Green Driving: Electric Car Problems Exposed

Electric vehicles are seen as a clean way to fight climate change and protect the environment. But, there’s a darker side to this shift. Electric cars come with their own set of problems and challenges¹⁶. Despite their growing popularity, with 2.5% of global sales in 2019, they’re not without their trade-offs¹⁶.

Electric cars need rare materials, some of which are mined in ways that harm the planet¹⁶. For instance, mining for lithium in Chile uses a lot of water¹⁶. Cobalt, another key battery material, is often mined in places where children work, raising ethical questions¹⁶.

Range anxiety and limited charging spots are big hurdles for electric car owners¹⁷. By 2025, electric cars might make up 13.7% of the market, but the demand for batteries and materials will grow too¹⁷. This raises worries about sustainability and social impacts.

The move to electric cars isn’t without its downsides¹⁷. They can cut fuel costs and are cheaper to run than traditional cars¹⁸. Yet, we must weigh the environmental and social effects as we aim for a greener future.

“The environmental impact of electric cars heavily depends on the cleanliness of the electricity grid powering them.” – Guillaume Majeau-Bettez, Norwegian University of Science and Technology¹⁷

We need to tackle the challenges of electric vehicles together, from policymakers to consumers¹⁷. By addressing these issues, we can make electric cars a true solution for a sustainable future¹⁶¹⁷¹⁸.

Blood Batteries and Child Labor

Most of the world’s cobalt comes from the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC). Children as young as seven mine it under dangerous conditions¹⁹. This has led to the term “blood batteries,” showing the link between EVs and human rights issues¹⁹.

Cobalt Mining in the Democratic Republic of Congo

The DRC mines over 50% of the world’s cobalt²⁰. Much of this comes from “artisanal” mines without safety or labor laws¹⁹. These mines are dangerous, causing serious health risks and accidents¹⁹.

Government officials say 20% of cobalt exports from the DRC come from these mines. This could mean even more actually do¹⁹.

Child labor is a big problem in the DRC’s cobalt mines. UNICEF says about 40,000 children work there, some as young as seven¹⁹. They work long hours for little pay in dangerous conditions²⁰.

“In southern DRC, at least 80 artisanal miners died underground between September 2014 and December 2015. The true figure remains unknown as many accidents go unrecorded.”²⁰

International groups are focusing on the human rights issues in the DRC’s cobalt mining²⁰. But, the demand for cobalt in EVs is high, and companies are slow to fix their supply chains²⁰.

The Responsible Cobalt Initiative includes companies like Apple and Samsung. They aim to address child labor in the DRC’s mines¹⁹. But, more action is needed to ensure cobalt is sourced ethically for EVs²⁰¹⁹²¹.

Chinese Dominance in the Cobalt Supply Chain

Chinese companies now lead the cobalt industry, causing worries about how they work and their impact²². They are the top producers and refiners of cobalt, with most coming from the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC)²². This gives them a big say in the electric vehicle (EV) industry, which needs cobalt for batteries.

Chinese firms are getting bigger in the DRC, a country rich in resources but also unstable²². Artisanal mining there provides a lot of the world’s cobalt, but it’s often dangerous and uses child labor²². This raises big questions about how they work and treat people, as Chinese companies get more powerful.

Chinese companies aren’t just big in mining²³. In 2020, a Chinese battery maker was working on a new EV battery without cobalt or nickel²². Tesla also made half of its vehicles in early 2022 with cobalt-free batteries²². This could lessen the need for cobalt and reduce Chinese control over the supply chain.

But, Chinese control over cobalt is still a big worry, especially with the DRC’s political issues and the chance of abuse²³. Having Chinese firms in charge raises doubts about how open and fair the cobalt supply chain is. This could affect the environment and people’s lives a lot.

As we move to electric cars, we need a cobalt supply chain that’s both sustainable and fair. Dealing with Chinese dominance in this area is key to making sure EVs are good for the planet and people.

Complicity of Major Automakers

Many top car companies are linked to unfair practices in the electric vehicle (EV) supply chain²⁴. Even though they say they don’t tolerate human rights violations, companies like Tesla, Volvo, Renault, Mercedes-Benz, and Volkswagen can’t keep a close eye on their supply chains²⁴. This means they let “blood cobalt” keep being used²⁴. This weak spot in the EV supply chain questions the ethical and green claims of these car makers.

It’s worrying that these companies work with Chinese firms in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC)²⁴. The DRC is known for child labor and dangerous mining conditions²⁴. The big car companies’ role in this issue is a big problem that needs fixing²⁴.

The car industry’s push against strong climate policies is also a problem²⁴. Japanese car makers, like Toyota, don’t support climate policies²⁴. Groups like the Alliance for Automotive Innovation in the U.S. and the Federal Chamber of Automotive Industries in Australia have weakened climate laws²⁴. This helps protect old car technologies, making it harder to move towards a greener future²⁴.

The actions of these big car companies raise doubts about the real sustainability and ethics of electric vehicles²⁴. We need stronger checks and openness to make sure moving to electric cars is good for people and the planet²⁴.

“Laggard automakers, especially in Japan, are hindering progress towards science-based climate policies.”²⁴

Conclusion

Switching to electric vehicles is a complex topic with both good and bad sides. Electric cars can cut down on emissions, making them a cleaner choice. For example, a Nissan Leaf EV in the UK in 2019 was much cleaner than the average gas car⁶.

However, there are problems with electric driving too. The mining of materials like lithium for EV batteries is often done in a way that harms the environment²⁵. Making EVs also uses a lot of energy, which can lead to more emissions²⁵. Plus, EVs have a shorter driving range and not enough places to charge them²⁶.

It’s important for the EV industry to tackle these issues. They need to make sure the move to electric cars is fair and good for the planet. Even though EVs are cleaner than gas cars, making the switch is not easy. We need a thoughtful plan to overcome the challenges of going green.

Source Links

1. The Dirty Secrets Of ‘Clean’ Electric Vehicles
2. Child labour, toxic leaks: the price we could pay for a greener future
3. Electric vehicles are stealth rainforest killers!
4. Revealed: how US transition to electric cars threatens environmental havoc
5. Electric vehicles: Good for public health and the planet – Fresh Energy
6. Factcheck: How electric vehicles help to tackle climate change
7. Are electric cars really eco-friendly? Maybe not as such much as you think.
8. The Environmental Impact of Battery Production for EVs
9. The Dark Secret Behind the Drive for Electric Vehicles
10. Factcheck: 21 misleading myths about electric vehicles – Carbon Brief
11. Are electric cars better for the environment? | RAC Drive
12. Electric cars have a road trip problem, even for the secretary of energy
13. The Dark Secret Behind the Drive for Electric Vehicles
14. Making Electric Vehicle Charging More Equitable Is Key to Our Clean Vehicle Future
15. Without access to charging stations, Black and Hispanic communities may be left behind in the era of electric vehicles
16. We must not overlook the dark side of electric vehicles
17. Darker side of electric cars in spotlight
18. Electric Vehicles in the Community: Benefits and Challenges – Clean Energy Group
19. The Dark Side of Electric Cars: Exploitative Labor Practices
20. Exposed: Child labour behind smart phone and electric car batteries
21. How ‘modern-day slavery’ in the Congo powers the rechargeable battery economy
22. Cobalt Mining: The Dark Side of the Energy Transition | Earth.Org
23. The dirty road to clean energy: How China’s electric vehicle boom is ravaging the environment
24. Toyota Ranked Worst For Climate Lobbying, But Almost All Automakers Complicit | Carscoops
25. Are Electric Car Batteries Bad for the Environment?
26. Electric Vehicles for Everyone? The Impossible Dream